Arrow to Bottom

39-245
Rapid Design through Virtual and Physical Prototyping

Carnegie Mellon University
Spring 2003

Course Index
HR

Design and Build Exercise

Section A

Team A Section A

Team A Geoff, Erin, Ruchi, Mark, Dave

A building B

A building B

A built by F

A built by F
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 33
     Material use rank: tie for 2 = 13 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: 67 minutes (estimate)
     Time rank: 3/6 = points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 0 points
     Design improvements: 0 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Time rank: 5/6 = 1 point

Total: 52/100 points

Team B Section A

Team B: Juliana, Alexis, Billy, Allison, Diana

 

B building Cheater Arch Designers

B building C

B built by A

B built by A

Design
     Enclosure: 5 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 33
     Material use rank: tie for 2 = 13 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Build time: 85 minutes (estimate)
     Time rank: 5/6 = 1 point

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 12 points
     Design improvements: 5 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Time rank: 4/6 = points

Total: 58/100 points

Team Cheater arch designers Section A

Cheater Arch Designers: Sarah, Lars, Ben, Neal

Cheater arch designers building D

Cheater Arch Designers building D

C built by B

Cheater Arch Designers built by B
Design
     Enclosure: 24 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 34 sheets
     Material use rank: tie for 3 = 10 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Build time: 70 minutes
     Time rank: 4/6 = 2 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 7 points
     Design improvements: 0 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 2/6 = 4 points

Total: 57/100 points

Team D Section A

Team D: Jason, Matt, Erik, Evan, Jared

Team D building Group X

D building E

D built by C

D built by Cheater Arch Designers
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 42 sheets
     Material use rank: 5/6 = 6 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: 65 minutes
     Time rank: 2/6 = 4 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points      Design improvements: 7 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Time rank: 1/6 = 5 points

Total: 72/100 points

Group X Section A

Group X: Nick, Stephen, Julia, Phillipe

Group X building F

Group X building F

E built by D

Group X built by D
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 34 sheets
     Material use rank: tie for 3 = 10 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Build time: 64 minutes
     Time rank: 1/6 = 5 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: 5 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 6/6 = 0 points

Total: 65/100 points

Team F Section A

Team F: Tanna, Marta, Emili, Tuan

Team F building A

Team F building Design A

F built by E

Team F's design built by Group X
Design
     Enclosure: 10
     Sheets of newspaper: 27 sheets
     Material use rank: 1/6 = 15 points
     Structural integrity: 0
     Build time: 70 minutes
     Time rank: 6/6 = 0 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: 5 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 3/6 = 3 points

Total: 43/100 points

Section B

Team A Section B

Team A, Yogesh, Jung, Trevor, Jay, June

A building B

A building B

A built by D

A built by D
Design
     Enclosure: 24 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 30 sheets
     Material use rank: 3/4 = 10 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: 55 minutes
     Time rank: 3/4 = 3 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: 0 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 2/4 = 4 points

Total: 56/100 points

Team B Section B

Team B: Trish, Joe, Divya, Jason, Chris

 

B building C

B building C

B built by A

 B built by A
Design
     Enclosure: 10 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 43 sheets
     Material use rank: 4/4 = 6 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: ?? minutes
     Time rank: 2/4 = 4 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: 8 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Time rank: 1/4 = 5 points

Total: 58/100 points

Team C Section B

Team C: Elijah, Dom, Wayne, Zavo, Roberto

C building D

C building D

C built by B

C built by B
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 27 sheets
     Material use rank: 2/4 = 12 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Build time: 47 minutes
     Time rank: 1/4 = 5 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: points: 5 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 4/4 = 0 points

Total: 67/100 points

Team D Section B

Team D, Jeff, Alex, Zach, Lara, Andrew, Jen

D building A

D building A

D built by C

D built by C
Design
     Enclosure: 20 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 22 sheets
     Material use rank: 1/5 = 15 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: 50 minutes
     Time rank: 4/4 = 0 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: 10 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 3/4 = 3 points

Total: 63/100 points

Section C

Team A Section C

Team A, Stephanie, Autumn, David, Bill, Josiah

A building B

A building B

A built by E

A built by E
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 45 sheets
     Material use rank: 5/5 = 6 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: 65 minutes
     Time rank: 2/5 = 4 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: 0 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 3/5 = 3 points

Total: 53/100 points

Team B Section C

Team B, Chris, Alex, Rohan, Derek, Luis

 

B building C

B building C

B built by A

B built by A
Design
     Enclosure: 5 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 40 sheets
     Material use rank: 4/5 = 8 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: 60 minutes
     Time rank: 3/5 = 3 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 15 points
     Design improvements: 5 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 1/5 = 5 points

Total: 41/100 points

Team C Section C

Team C: Shaina, Andrew, Simon, Russ, Jose

C building D

C building D

C built by B

C built by B
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 36 sheets
     Material use rank: 3/5 = 10 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Build time: ?? minutes
     Time rank: 1/5 = 5 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 13 points
     Design improvements: 10 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Time rank: 4/5 = 2 points

Total: 75/100 points

Team D Section C

Team D: Aubrey, Matt, Tommy, Piama, Naoki

D building E

D building E

D built by C

D built by C
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 33 sheets
     Material use rank: 2/5 = 12 points
     Structural integrity: 10 points
     Build time: 60 minutes
     Time rank: 4/5 = 2 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent:13 points
     Design improvements: 10 points
     Structural integrity: 8 points
     Time rank: 5/5 = 0 points

Total: 80/100 points

Team E Section C

Team E: Sanket, Charlie, Paul, Justin, Eli

E building A

E building A

E built by D

E built by D
Design
     Enclosure: 25 points
     Sheets of newspaper: 32 sheets
     Material use rank: 1/5 = 15 points
     Structural integrity: 8 points
     Build time: 60 minutes
     Time rank: 5/5 = 0 points

Build
     Adherence to design intent: 10 points
     Design improvements: 5 points
     Structural integrity: 0 points
     Time rank: 2/5 = 4 points

Total: 67/100 points

HR

Class home page       Arrow to top       Mail to sfinger

sfinger@ri.cmu.edu