Sorry for the delay: agree that the bonds are "Not Contingent" but I would
like to see Potts' opinion.




Robert Pickel <RPICKEL@isda.org> on 15 Oct 2001 12:06

To:   ISDA BOARD <BOARD@isda.org>
cc:   Kimberly Summe <KSumme@isda.org>
      Louise Marshall <LMarshall@isda.org>
                                               
 Our Ref:               Your Ref:              
                                               


Subject:  Credit Derivatives Issue


******************************************************************
 This message originated from the Internet. Its originator may or
 may not be who they claim to be and the information contained in
 the message and any attachments may or may not be accurate.
******************************************************************

You should be aware that an issue is currently under extensive debate in
the
credit derivative area resulting from the insolvency of Railtrack in the
UK.
ISDA has been asked by some participants in the market to make a statement
regarding a provision of its Credit Derivatives Definitions. Others are
either still considering their position or would prefer that ISDA not issue
a statement.

Specifically, the discussion relates to the deliverability of convertible
bonds of Railtrack. There is no dispute that a Credit Event occurred. What
is in dispute is whether the bonds satisfy the definition of "Not
Contingent" under the Definitions, which is a characteristic typically
required of deliverable obligations. This characteristic requires that the
payment or repayment of principal on the bonds not be subject to a
contingency. The bonds are convertible into equity of Railtrack at the
option of the holder or, in certain limited circumstances, at the option of
the trustee for the bondholder. The provision for the trustee to exercise
the conversion (sometimes referred to as a "widows and orphans" clause) is
a
standard clause in bonds issued in England and is intended to protect
bondholders who may have inadvertently failed to exercise their conversion
right when it would be clearly beneficial economically for them to do so.
In
the case of Railtrack, conversion would not have been economically
beneficial at any time recently, but nevertheless the right of the trustee
to convert exists.

A draft statement has been prepared for consideration by the Credit
Derivatives Market Practice Committee, which I have attached for your
review. The statement refers to two documents that are in draft form, the
User's Guide to the Definitions (which is scheduled to be published in the
next week or two) and a Supplement currently under consideration by the
"group of six" subgroup of the Committee. In each of these documents, we
suggest that "plain vanilla" convertible bonds should satisfy the "Not
Contingent" characteristic and should, therefore, be deliverable. "Plain
vanilla" convertible bonds for this purpose include bonds where conversion
is at the option of the holder of the trustee.

A meeting of a number of dealers based in London (not an ISDA meeting) is
scheduled for Tuesday. It is not likely that we will publish anything prior
to that meeting.

I would appreciate your views on whether we should issue any statement
regarding this situation. We are continuing to poll members for their views
on whether this type of market statement would be appropriate. We are also
discussing with Allen & Overy and with Clifford Chance and Linklaters how
we
might achieve a legal basis for making the statement. Please share your
views with the other addressees of this email, as they are coordinating the
views of members.

Bob





********************************************************************
 This  message and any attachments are confidential to the ordinary
 user  of the e-mail address to which it was addressed and may also
 be  privileged.   If  you  are not the addressee you may not read,
 copy, forward, disclose  or  use  any  part  of  the  message  or  
 its attachments and if you have received this message in error, 
 please notify  the sender immediately by return e-mail and delete 
 it from your system.

 Internet  communications  cannot  be  guaranteed  to  be secure or
 error-free  as  information could be intercepted, corrupted, lost,
 arrive  late or contain viruses.  The sender therefore does not
 accept  liability  for  any  errors or omissions in the context of
 this  message  which  arise  as a result of Internet transmission.
 
 Any opinions contained in this message are those of the author and 
 are not given or endorsed by the HSBC Group company or office 
 through which this message is sent unless otherwise clearly 
 indicated in this message and the authority of the author to so 
 bind the HSBC entity referred to is duly verified.

********************************************************************