----- Forwarded by Steven J Kean/NA/Enron on 10/11/2000 01:17 PM -----

	"IssueAlert" <IssueAlert@scientech.com>
	10/11/2000 06:30 AM
		 
		 To: 
		 cc: 
		 Subject: Online Niche Players Capitalize on Natural-Gas Shortage, Bypass 
Utilities

http://www.consultrci.com

************************************************************************ 

SCIENTECH's E-commerce InfoGrid uncovers the efforts of energy-related 
companies in the ever-growing field of electronic commerce. A sample can 
be viewed at:
 http://www.consultrci.com/web/infostore.nsf/Products/InfoGrid
************************************************************************

===============================================================
SCIENTECH IssueAlert, October 11, 2000
Online Niche Players Capitalize on Natural-Gas Shortage, Bypass Utilities
By: Will McNamara, Director, Electric Industry Analysis
===============================================================

SmartEnergy, a Con Edison competitor, is offering New York and Westchester 
consumers price protection with the ability to lock-in today's natural-gas 
rates for a period of one year. In a separate announcement, myHomeKey.com 
announced that it will offer energy savings packages designed to reduce 
energy consumption and lower rates for customers in the face of rising 
energy costs.

ANALYSIS: As reports continue to accumulate that a natural-gas shortage 
will send prices skyrocketing this winter (see my IssueAlert from Oct. 
9 on the subject), the most common response from electric utilities has 
been to warn their customers that they will see higher rates over the next 
few months. I can point to several examples. Minneapolis-based Xcel Energy 
announced a few weeks back that its natural-gas customers could face heating 
bills that are 35 to 50 percent higher than their bills last winter. Dominion 
East Ohio has warned its residential customers that they can expect to 
pay about $70 more per month for natural gas from November through January. 
And the warnings are coming not only in the Midwest and Northeast*where 
low winter temperatures drive up energy bills every year*but in the West 
as well. In California, PG&E warns that its customers can expect to see 
their winter bills increase by about $25, to an average bill of $75 (compared 
to $50 last winter). These are just a few examples of utility companies 
across the United States playing damage control, trying to minimize the 
customer outrage when customers suddenly see their bills double or triple.

Along with their warnings, these utilities give reasons*perhaps seen as 
excuses by the public*for the rising cost of energy. There is a shortage 
of natural gas across the country, brought about by a drop-off in production. 
It was an unusually hot summer, which depleted supplies for energy. Demand 
in general has grown to surprising levels.

Meanwhile, start-up online companies that many of us have not even heard 
of are using the rise in natural-gas prices as a golden marketing 
opportunity, 
and attempting to take business away from traditional utility companies. 
SmartEnergy is a perfect example. In existence just since April 1999,  
SmartEnergy offers electricity and natural gas to residential and small 
business customers. According to EnergyGuide.com, for an average home in 
New York City, SmartEnergy's natural-gas rates typically have run about 
$189 per month, compared Con Edison's $140. Under its new promotion, 
SmartEnergy's 
plan for natural gas guarantees that New York City and Westchester gas 
customers who sign on with their service now will be locked into current 
natural-gas rates for the next 12 months. This promotion comes at an ideal 
time for those who opt to switch, as natural-gas prices should begin their 
projected sharp increase over the next few weeks. Based on recent forecasts, 
SmartEnergy is claiming that Con Edison customers who make the switch can 
expect to save up to 40 percent on their energy through the winter months. 
The start-up company also is offering 500 United Airlines Mileage Plus 
Reward Miles credit and $25 sign-up bonus to entice customers away from 
Con Edison. 

Based on the available information about SmartEnergy, it is unclear how 
the online provider will be able to guarantee the 40-percent reduction 
in natural-gas rates. I would presume that SmartEnergy has entered into 
some hedging strategies to minimize its risk in the event that natural-gas 
prices remain high into the next year. Any prudent provider would have 
a hedging strategy to protect itself, and locking itself into 12-month 
contracts without its own contracts for obtaining natural gas at spot market 
prices would certainly raise questions about the future of SmartEnergy. 
In addition, SmartEnergy will have difficulty in recruiting customers away 
from Con Edison and other utility providers. Many customers still have 
reservations about signing on with an online company that they do not know. 
There will be some customers who jump at the chance to lock in current 
rates for 12 months, but many others will stick with the company that they 
know even if their rates increase.

I did a quick search around Con Edison's Website to see if it might be 
offering an alternative offer to retain its customers, but could find nothing 
that the utility is doing to specifically address the projected increase 
in natural-gas prices this winter. Con Edison does offer a level billing 
program in which customers receive a consistent bill amount each month, 
alleviating fluctuation in their bills. Yet, as a utility company, Con 
Edison has a standard offer of service that regulators closely monitor. 
It is possible that Con Edison could request changes to the standard offer 
service, which would likely need to be approved by the New York Public 
Service Commission. The PSC could agree, or determine that the competitive 
offers by providers such as Smart Energy are a positive result of 
deregulation. 
In addition, Con Edison could be hampered by fuel contracts that may not 
allow it much flexibility with regard to lowering its rates. Overall, Con 
Edison probably does not have a lot of flexibility regarding the rates 
it can charge customers, thereby making this offer from SmartEnergy difficult 
to beat.

The other online start-up taking advantage of natural-gas prices is 
myHomeKey.com, 
which made a recent promise to reduce home heating, oil, natural-gas, and 
electricity rates. The marketing route that this online start-up is taking 
is energy efficiency*teaching households how to more effectively use their 
energy and, hopefully, save money as a result. Energy is not the only service 
of the myHomeKey.com; it is also involved in home maintenance and repair, 
appliances, home monitoring and moving services. Yet, I learned that 
myHomeKey.com 
just recently launched co-branded sites with KeySpan Corp. and TXU Energy 
Services to "provide millions of local customers" with the ability to check 
energy efficiency in their homes.

What's important to note about these two developments is the advantage 
that online energy providers have over traditional utilities. As utilities 
try to disengage themselves from regulatory-bound rate structures, online 
companies have the freedom and flexibility to offer attractive products 
and billing options to customers in deregulated states. There are the online 
providers that we know about, such as Utility.com and Essential.com. 
Utility.com 
has not yet started to sell natural gas, although it has established a 
partnership with Sempra Energy in which Sempra Energy Trading will sell 
natural gas in deregulated markets via the Utility.com Web site. Utility.com 
plans to start selling natural gas by the end of this year, but it has 
not developed any marketing campaign in this regard. Essential.com continues 
to open up its service across the Mid-Atlantic and Northeast regions. Yet, 
on a weekly basis, new start-up online energy providers surface, eager 
to grab their own share of the retail market. 

I also wonder where The New Power Company is in all of this rush to 
capitalize 
on the marketing opportunities surrounding the rise in natural-gas prices. 
It would seem like a natural for TNPC to make a big splash with its own 
marketing efforts, as it already promises lower prices for both natural 
gas and electricity. In any event, as the natural-gas shortage may become 
a public relations nightmare for utility companies across the country, 
it conversely could work to the advantage of the more agile online providers
==============================================================
Read about SCIENTECH's new PowerHitter interview with Jeff Sterba, Chairman 

and CEO of the Public Service Company of New Mexico at: 
http://www.consultrci.com 
===============================================================

SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let 
us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH 
information products including e-commerce and telecom in the electric utility 
industry. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily 
IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and 
email address or register directly at:

http://www.consultrci.com/web/infostore.nsf/Products/IssueAlert


Sincerely,

Will McNamara
Director, Electric Industry Analysis
wmcnamara@scientech.com
===============================================================
Feedback regarding SCIENTECH's IssueAlert should be sent to 
wmcnamara@scientech.com
===============================================================

SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are compiled based on independent analysis by 
SCIENTECH 
consultants.  The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not 
intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed or to 
be the basis for investment decisions of any kind.  SCIENTECH's sole purpose 
in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective 
regarding 
the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing 
reputation as an expert on energy and telecommunications issues.

Copyright 2000.  SCIENTECH, Inc.

If you do not wish to receive any further IssueAlerts from SCIENTECH, please 
reply to this message and in the body of the email type "remove."