Various physical properties of water with IE structures are measured. Compared with ordinary water, there is an approximate 20% decrease in dielectric constant for IE water at MHz as an increase of emf generated by IE water between two identical stainless steel electrodes, and an increase in resistivity to AC current. Fluorescence at 298 nm peak is seen in IE water but not in ordinary water. From the thermal variation of UV absorption spectrum, one can estimate the amount of IE structure to be up to 3%. The elevation of boiling point due to IE structure can then be used to calculate the molecular weight of IE structure to be the same as water molecule.
Recently it has been suggested that stable rigid structures (called IE structures which stands for ice formed under electric field) can be formed from water molecules at room temperature and normal pressure.1 Rod-like structures are identified in photographs taken by transmission electron microscope. The physical hypothesis behind these IE structures is that the electric dipole moment of water molecules play a dominant role to attract themselves together to form IE structures, which itself may have some electric dipole moment. To justify such an hypothesis, it is necessary to look for electrical and other properties of these IE structures. We have measured five different properties: dielectric constants; the electromotive force (emf) using two identical electrodes; resistivity; fluorescence; stability as a function of temperature. We find these properties are different from pure water. Pure water shall be defined to be used in this paper as having 18 megaohms of resistance and having less than several parts per billion Total Dissolved Solids, which for our experiment is supplied by Millipore RO Plus system.
2. Dielectric Constant
Water molecule has a very large electric dipole moment and is forced to rotate to respond to an alternate external electric field. Hence water as a liquid has a very large dielectric constant 80. If water molecules group together to form larger structures such as the IE structure that is proposed, then the resulting structured water should have a larger dielectric constant. When an external AC field is applied, these IE structures will respond and cause a change of the dielectric constant. We use the Hewlett Packard Corp. 4192A LF Impedance Analyzer (5Hz ~ 13 MHz) to measure the pure and the imaginary parts of the dielectric constant of structured water and pure water. This is shown in Fig. 1. The absolute value of dielectric constant and its phase of IE structured water is also presented separately in Fig. 1b. There is a minimum value of the phase at around 1 kHz. The distilled water has a dielectric value 80 at frequency ~ 106 Hz, and the IE structured water has a twenty percent smaller dielectric constant.
3. Electromotive Force
It is well known in electrochemistry that an emf is generated between two different electrodes in a solution and no emf is generated between same electrodes in a solution. We immerse a pair of stainless electrodes in IE structured water, and we have found that a finite emf of 10 mV or more is generated. In Fig. 2 (a), we have shown one typical curve for a concentrated IE structured water that lasts for an hour. The first 2 to 3 minutes irregular reading, then approaches a maximum of 38 mV, and then drops slowly over the next hour. Figure 2 (b) shows emf for a variety of IE structure water. The physical explanation of these figures is that the electric dipoles of the IE structures are pointing at different direction randomly in water in the beginning. As the first electric dipole attaches to the electrodes an emf is set up between the electrodes. This emf will force a more regular alignment of IE structures in water between the two electrodes. The more aligned the electric dipoles are, the higher the emf. However as time goes on the thermal vibration of water molecules will tend to cause disorder in the alignment of IE structures. The emf will decrease as a result.
If we stir the IE structure water with a glass rod during measurement procedure, the emf will alter immediately, and then slowly returns to its original value. The amount of IE structures in the IE structured water is small, and their orientations are random. So the measurements are different each time as shown in Fig. 2 (b), but clearly there is a common quality to the measurement which differs from that of pure water. The amount of emf measured also depends on the surface of the electrode. The sharper microstructure on the metal surface is expected to generate a bigger electric field, and hence a larger realignment of IE structures. These microstructures on the metal can be broken or screened by the IE structures or created in cleaning by acid. When we wash the electrodes with nitric acid for cleaning purpose, we get a larger emf with the same IE structured water.
We insert the same electrodes in pure water (reverse osmosis water from Ultrapure Millipore plus system). An emf of 3 ~ 7 mV is also seen. The emf is much smaller and changes much less in time. The control sample for emf measurement is no longer pure water because it is expected that water molecules cluster together due to the hydrogen bonding as discussed in flickering cluster model of water inside.2 These flickering water clusters the electric dipole moment of their constitute water molecules probably do not completely cancel one another; therefore, these water clusters have some residue electric dipole moment. These small amount of electric dipole moment probably constitute the emf that is observed here.
Some general comments on experimental procedure in measuring various physical properties of water with IE structure are in order. Firstly, the IE structures are created not in a completely controlled fashion. The amount and size of IE structures are not controlled precisely. These IE structures also keep on changing in size and amount in water if it is disturbed. A qualitative definite results are reproducible, but a quantitative reproducible results for some measurements are almost impossible. Secondly, IE structures are electrical in nature. They attach to container very strongly and cannot be easily washed away. They also break up easily and reproduce. Sometimes the more you wash with the cleanest water available to you, the more IE structures you may end up with. For each measurement, it is important to establish a base line without the influence of IE structures. Otherwise measurements become meaningless and not reproducible.
If the IE structures in water are electric dipoles, any ion moving close to them in water will be attracted to them. When ions are attached to a much larger size IE structures which could be as big as micron size, their movement in water will become slower. The mobility of ion µi becomes the mobility µ of ion plus the IE structure, which is larger. Hence the conductivity of structured water which is proportional to the mobility will also decrease. Or the resistivity will increase. We use standard resistivity meter constructed by omega. CDB-94, which consists of a pair of platinum electrodes, operating at 100 Hz with a voltage of 1 volt. The results are shown in Fig. 3. There is an abrupt large change in the first minute after the voltage is being applied probably due to the rapid orientation of the IE structures in water. Then as alternative voltage drives the ions attached to IE structures back and forth. It is equivalent to shaking them mechanically. IE structures break down into smaller pieces and grow bigger. Then more ions will be attached to more IE structures that decreases again the conductivity.
It is, in general, easy to conceive a background mechanism that increases conductivity of pure water because most dirt contains some soluble materials that produce more ions in water and hence bigger conductivity. It is difficult to construct some simple background signal that decreases conductivity measurement. We have performed our experiment in a clean room environment, which is confirmed by the constant value of conductivity of pure water.
5. Fluorescence Spectra
We use Hitachi 850 Fluorescence Spectrophotometer to compare IE structured water with pure water. For pure water and ice I, there is no fluorescence spectra, whereas there is a district peak at 298 nm using various excitation UV light at 200, 230, 276, 285 nm. This is shown in Fig. 4 and 5. The interpretation is that with a big cluster of molecules in IE structures, electrons may be shared among different molecules in the same IE structures, which can be excited by UV light to a new state. Fluorescence light is emitted when the new excited state jumps back to ground state.
6. Thermal Stability
An interesting question on IE structures is how stable is it with respect to heat? We have put IE structured water in quartz cells and observe its UV transmission characteristics. We prepare different strength of IE structured water by method described in previous paper. The strength of the IE structured water is given by the UV transmission in percentage in reference to pure water. We use a dual beam Perkin Elmer Lambda 2S spectrophotometer. One reference cell is filled with pure water and the other cell is filled with structured water. The UV transmission T is a ratio of readings through the two cells. The sample cell is first filled with pure cell to get a baseline of almost T = 100% reading. Then the sample cell is filled with IE structured water with various strength for UV transmission measurement. The difference of transmission of these two UV transmission measurement at wave length 190 nm is used as a measure of the strength of various IE structured water. So a T = 2.3% solution is a weak solution, and 80% is a strong solution. Then we measure the UV transmission characteristic for 2.4%, 20%, 40%, 60%, 80% and 96% solution as a function of temperature. The cell holding the sample is heated up through warm water bath gradually from room temperature to 80°C and then cool down. We have shown the results in Fig. 6. We also find that as the cell cools down from 80°C to room temperature, UV transmission characteristic returns indicating that the IE structures are stable under heating to at least 80°C.
The measured absorbance A is a linear combination of those from water Aw and IE structures AI:
We have found about 20% decrease in dielectric constant for IE water at 106Hz, as compared with ordinary water. The emf generated by IE water for identical stainless steel electrodes is much more than ordinary water. Passing small amount of AC current through IE water increases its resistivity significantly. Normal dirt in water has an opposite effect.
Fluorescence at 298 nm peak is seen in IE water but not in ordinary water. IE is very stable in hot temperature up to 121°C. Different thermal response of UV absorption spectrum of IE water enables us to estimate the amount of IE structures in water to be as high as three percent in some cases.